I think the multigenre autobiography would be a good assignment for the beginning of the year. Students will just have come back from summer vacation and their brains probably won't be up to par. The assignment doesn't require a lot of deep thought, but a lot can be learned from it. Also, there might be new students in your classroom and this would be an easy way to break the ice and get students better acquainted with one another. I like the idea of giving students some time in class to work on the project, so if they have any pertinent questions you can try to help them out.
One thing that I think would work better when showing the presentations, is to have a time restraint that is the same for everyone. When introducing the project, I think I would say that it can be no more than seven minutes and that if you bring it to class with more than that, then you won't be allowed to present. It's not fair to the people at the end, who only got like five minutes to present and others took like 15 minutes. In order to keep the presentations fair, having equal time before it starts would help solve that. It also is important that you make sure students aren't presenting to try and persuade other students to like what they like. It's OK to think what you liked was the best, but it's not OK to be overbearing and try to make others guilty for not liking it. The last restriction I could think of is that if you're going to ask everyone to write comments about others presentations, then you make sure everyone writes the comments. It's not fair to the students, who spent time writing thoughtful responses to others, yet some of those others didn't even take the time to send any responses at all. If it was my classroom, I would give all of the students enough strips of paper for the number of students in the classroom minus themselves, so they can write their responses on there. Then at the end of the period, the students will pass back their comment strips. The comment wouldn't have to be elaborate and would not be a strict question, just anything to comment on a specific of their presentation. Each student will count their comment strips to make sure everyone has the exact same amount.
One idea I got from watching the shows in class was that you could have students pick three favorites from everybody's presentations. It could be a movie, book, or tv show. Then you could list all of the favorites and have students break up into groups based on their favorite and do a group project on that title. This would further the getting to know you aspect by bringing together what may seem to be different students with an interest in the same move, book, tv show, etc.
I completely agree with you and the revisions that you would make to the multigenre autobiography. I believe that this project is a really good way for students to learn about their classmates. I agree that students should write down some of their favorite texts in their peers presentations, I also found it to be interesting that you would use this as a way to group students. I had never thought about doing something like that, but I do believe it is a great idea. The students in groups will know from the very beginning that they at least have one thing in common with all of their group members. Lastly, I too believe we as educators should incorporate meaningful literature into our classroom. Sometimes, students will identify more with texts if they can apply it to their life in some way.
ReplyDelete